I think what Count Florida was saying is that the genesis of this thread is what tier benefits do we prefer, not the all inclusive debate that has been done ad nauseum if you have been here long. The tier thing is not going to include all-inclusive option per their website, as that is not an option on this line except for WC. So he suggested we talk about the other perks that we might like, so that Radisson could hear(read) them. In doing so (sorry, Count) he did expound on his opinion of the very issue he was asking us to stop discussing.

Donna, the thing about Silversea, if you ever "shop them" is that their prices are so much more expensive than Radisson. Other than the all inclusive, I see from my one cruise (that I loved) there are no benefits. Everything seems the same, at least it did to me from my one cruise. They just don't discount till closer into the cruises, and then they offer comparable prices on some cruises~