I would definately prefer what Crystal and Seabourn do for their loyal passengers as apposed to what Radisson plans to do. The one category upgrade doesn't mean much as some passengers are already getting higher upgrades then that. A free cruise would sound VERY good to me. I agree with the comments regarding dining room reservations. Marc are you sure about the way Crystal counts their segments if you are on a WC?.I think there has been a lot of good imput on this particular site and I hope the powers to be are listening.