On my one cruise on Silversea Shadow, I think my expectations were for it to be much better than RSSC, if that were possible. Like Ngaire said, BLINK and you think you are on Radisson. That is in so many words what I reported in my review back in March. Other than the totally all-inclusive nature of SS, there are a few more differences that are pretty objective. Lots of people gather at "The Bar" before and after dinner, due to all-inclusive. I remember particularly on Formal night it was packed after dinner, with several of the men wearing kilts, which leads to the passenger mix. Many more "international" passengers on SS, and I really enjoyed that. Everyone seemed to enjoy mixing. Those Aussies are fun-lovers!
Subjectively, I enjoyed the entertainment more on Silversea, and I know the line is no more known for being the best than is RSSC. On this particular cruise, the CD, I think, was a younger woman from Tennessee who was trained in opera, and had other singing talents as well. She gave 2 great shows There was also a very talented and funny ventriloquist. Every cruise has different entertainment. This one just seemed to touch my taste both in variety and quality.
It is interesting to hear from Ngaire that the older SS ships have smaller cabins like the Diamond. I didn't realize that. I loved our cabin on the Shadow. Just like the Navigator/Voyager, except that they managed to get two sinks (not necessary for me) instead of one.