I agree that Ngaire did an excellent job of weighing in on both the pros and cons.
She made it VERY clear from the get-go that she (personally) does not like fixed seating due to the inability to dine when and with whom you choose. She also acknowledged that she is not into singing/dancing acts. I have to agree with hrprof...I can't tolerate fixed seating and a balcony is a must!
This is why it's great that we all have such options when choosing cruise lines and ships. There is something that "fits" everyone
