Welcome Mark S.! Always nice to hear a new voice in the crowd. I agree with you that EVERY line (mass market or luxury) has negatives and positives. For my husband and I often it's the people we meet who make the difference from an "okay cruise" to a really memorable one. While I very much enjoy RSSC...I would never limit myself to just one line. That's like saying you would only go to the same restaurant every time you eat out. Sometimes you want a romantic, upscale dinner for two....sometimes you want a big, raucous,family-friendly restaurant. Variety is the spice of life!
But what I like best about this forum is that while many are true RSSC loyalists, others are willing to admit that other lines exist. And, also, you won't find a more helpful group of people anywhere.


Bobbi