Comparing Silversea to Radisson? BLINK when you are on the Whisper or Shadow and you might be confused and think you are on the Navigator. Built in the same ship yards.
The key differences being the following (excluding the Diamond or the PG that are not the same type of new ship).
Whisper and Shadow newer and larger with cabins like Navigator and Voyager. Silversea are NOT all balcony cabins they do have non balcony Vista cabins.
Wind and Cloud smaller ship with the non balcony Vista cabins 240 sq. ft like the Diamond size. The Mariner cabins are smaller than Navigator or Voyager without the balcony they are 252 sq. ft. Still larger than the Wind and the Cloud cabins plus the Mariner suites all have balconies.
Silversea vs Radisson - general
Silversea has Open Bar all ships
Silversea vs Voyager
Not as many alternate dining options on Silversea
Cabins about the same but double sinks on Whisper and Shadow
Silversea vs Mariner
Not as many alternate dining options
Bigger cabins on Silversea Whisper and Shadow - smaller cabins on Wind and Cloud.
I have had perfect cruises I have had cruises with service problems on BOTH lines. Each cruise is unique and what bothers one person will not bother another person. I always say take the "this is perfect review and then the this is terrible review" mix them up and in the middle is probably how most people would feel about the ship and crew.
The food, service, and entertainment is very equal to me on both of these lines.
That actually started to not be as simple to compare because of the variance in both Silversea ships cabins and Radisson ships cabins.