Well, guys it is time for me to “chime in” on this board. I am the one who started the thread on the CC Crystal board re: Ngaire’s Crystal report (which much to my chagrin has now been deleted- those Gestapo methods at work again). It was my intention to obtain some responses from the Crystal cruisers to Ngaire's opinions. From reading this LCT board in reaction to Ngaire's report, I felt that, while she is certainly entitled to her opinion, it was a wee bit "skewed", to her personal tastes. In the first place, it was not a "normal" Crystal cruise with 250 TA's aboard and also it was her first Crystal cruise.
To be quite honest with you, our first RSSC cruise was on the Navigator to the Far East and it was not one of our better cruises. The officers and crew were surely and not amenable to solve our traveling companion’s and our own reasonable requests. The overall layout of the Navigator, to us personally, was not as passenger friendly as say, the Mariner. That said, we have since cruised with Rad 3 other times (all on the Mariner) and will be on one segment of the World Cruise in April.
I certainly respect Ngaire's analysis and opinions and she is looking at the Crystal with a very inquisitive and experienced eye. I commend this.
However, I did feel that in some of Ngaire's earlier reports concerning the food, the production shows (only a tad better in costumes than Crystal’s, in her opinion) and the lack of meeting people (and missing her LCT buddies) not a Crystal experience which we have had.
I can also see why Paul59 took exception to Ngaire's report, as a frequent Crystal ( and Radisson) cruiser). I too believe that Paul59 did not express himself properly, but I know him and have traveled with him and I do not believe that he was deliberately vindictive. IMO, he was doing nothing more ( but a bit too personally) than protecting his cruise line just as many of you LCTers “shunned” Crystal based solely on Ngaire's report.
Actually, one of my biggest gripes with the "formal" Crystal experience is the room service. On RSSC the room service waiter sets the table very nicely, presents the food in an appetizing manner and it is placed on a larger table mounted on the small table (the one used for reading materials, etc). On Crystal, the stewardess comes in, drops the tray on the tiny table and leaves with all the food piled upon each other. Not very appetizing, to say the least.
Overall, Ngaire's report and comments are right on point from her personal point of view. For example, we like the two seatings at dinner (cause we have the same table and excellent wait staff), the formality of the afternoon tea ( like the personal service and attention, but miss trivia after the tea, as on RSSC).
I agree with Ngaire that the RSSC cabins are nicer and bigger ( love the walk-in closets and the privacy curtains on the RSSC ships), wine with dinner and liquor set ups in the rooms are a nice "extra" ( not a deal breaker but nice), glass of champagne on embarkation and a chilled bottle awaiting in the room, internet costs very reasonable ( as compared with the "highway-robbery" charges on Crystal).
In Crystal's corner we love the Bistro, as does Ngaire, where you can get any type of coffee and snack almost all day, and for us, we love Crystal’s extraordinary entertainment, in the production shows, the lounges, the lectures, and the "on board" activities. In our opinion, the production shows on RSSC are mediocre, at best, as compared with Crystal.
Again, I thought Ngaire's reports and comments very valid, fair and balanced and in many respects right on point ( so much so that I bet Paul59 would also agree as to their validity) Also, they contained her own personal preferences which she is certainly entitled to.
While she is not my TA, I have spoken with her on a number of occasions and found her to be very knowledgeable, friendly and extremely amenable to assist. (Besides the fact that she was the originator and sponsor of this wonderfully informative LCT board.)
My intent, again, in posting on the Crystal CC board was not to bring out "vindictiveness" among the two boards but constructive comments from experienced travelers from both cruise lines. In a way it succeeded and in fact, there are now (coincidentally) many more daily posts on the CC Crystal board and can you believe, they are actually asking for "roll calls" for various cruises (never have seen that before)
Y’all have a Happy and Healthy Holiday Season and New Year.