Crystal is quite formal -- both in the assigned seating and the formal attire on usually three nights of the cruise. I love seeing my husband in a tux (he enjoys wearing one) and we love dancing at the various parties. I don't know how the postings on that thread spiraled up like they did. I found her comments to be honest and mostly favorable (when you pass the assigned seating and charges for wine and gratuities). The current thread seemed also to be getting out of hand so I made my comments. She certainly doesn't need me to defend her, but I thought the comments should stop. Judith