I read your review, and I was happy to see it, especially since we're exploring that itinerary for the future.
I will never book an OS, however, so their being so scarce wouldn't bother me. I'd be content with a PH, or even an A (not below that.) Marc, why would you want to base the comparison on an OS, and not a PH, since the PH approximates the size of an H?
I too am interested to hear what amenities or perks you had being in an OS, that other passengers didn't receive. You mentioned water, but I wonder if you were treated differently.