Ted,
Thanks for taking the time to write such an excellent well thought out comparison! We too have considered trying "O" and thinking about the bottom line $$. It may be different in our case as we definitely do lounges and such.
Drinking the difference in cost between the two would require immediate admission to rehab at the conclusion of the cruise assuming that one survived the cruise
Maybe you had Tom and me in mind (and a few other LCTers) :D
That's what great about cruising...something that appeals to everyone