I would agree with you Tom that the consumer does think like that a lot of the time. For me I just never had a problem presenting my cruise card for things, I mean you have to carry it anyway, to get on and off the ship and to get into your stateroom. If you need it to pay for drinks or water, it just doesnt seem like a big deal to me.
I mean if your staying at a Ritz Carlton or Four Seasons you need to sign for things. Regarding Oceania I would not have a problem paying $3.50 for a big bottle of Evian in my room, when it costs $2.50 at your local Walgreens.

FV