As someone who has done both R and O - I think your assessment is right on target. I would do either one based on the itinerary, price and timing. We booked O for the Baltics. 14 days instead of 7 for the same fare and more ports. Concierge Class so the room is the same as the PG as opposed to G on Voyager. There were several things we liked better than R and some better on R over O. Just like cruising the mass market lines, sometimes you might need to have an alternative means of travel. Variety is the spice of life.