The comparison for a PH on O is most appropriate to a Cat H on Regent. The amenities and cabin size are comparable except for beverages and tips. Actually in a PH on O, you get a Butler which you do not get on R in the H category. If you are an SSS member, you do not get those benefits. But for the price differential to pay for internet or telephone and tips was still worthwhile. The bathrooms on R are hard to match at sea but are not a deal breaker either. Tub over shower and adequate sink - but for one at a time.