I would be interested in the assessment of cost (i.e., value) comparing the Oceania OS to the Voyager or Mariner Cat H. I have always believed that the best value for me is on a ship where the cheapest accomodations are up to my standards; of course, this includes food, service, amenities, etc. in the definition "up to my standards." In this situation, others are subsidizing your enjoyment of the rest of the ship.
Many have said that the Oceania PH is a good comparison to the Regent Cat H; however, here you are subsidizing others. Also, I understand that the Oceania PH doesn't have some of the benefits mentioned in your review.
It will be interesting to see how Oceania versus Regent play out over time as part of PCH. They have stated that they are keeping the two lines separate as they focus on different portions of the market. If the customers do not feel that there is a difference, then it is harder for the company to charge two different price points.