Boy, this is really bad news. Because if our recent experience is any indication (by virtue of our cruise values, not those of anyone else), the only "luxury" dining venue that existed on our recent PG trip was Apicius. I would bet you anything this change is a downgrade. That's the way PG is going. And, with apologies, Ngaire, "they won't know the difference" is not a defense. We'll see! But given the trends we have seen, do you really think this is an improvement? Patrick