Pat I did not mean that it was a defense that first time cruisers would not know the difference I just meant if you have sailed on other RSSC ships you would be more aware of the difference. I need you and Fred to write for me you both are so talented. It is in the brain I just cant put it on the paper!!!!

Food is so subjective. I personally prefer plain food but high quality plain food. I dont like Fois Gras, Caviar, but that is just me. So if the Bistro offers simpler but top quality food for the boring palate like mine people like me could really like it. I was not going to eat at Apicius on PIP but people said how good it was so I got a reservation and I will say I really liked it since now there were choices. Things are always changing.

On the other hand I have no idea if it will be an improvement or a downgrade. That remains to be seen. On first impressions I will say it sounds more like a downgrade but I think we wont know that until it changes and we get many opinions.

Jeanine food posts always generate a lot of responses. I think it is because we all like such different things. Just like this post turned into who liked Apicius and who did not. Different strokes for different folks.

It makes me think of my experience in Egypt when we were served a home cooked meal in an Egyptian home. That lady went to so much trouble and I ate the food but OH it was so difficult. I am sure to their taste buds is was exceptional but to mine --- well as I said different strokes for different folks.