I'll add my 2 cents. When we did our b2b in February 2003, we also preferred L'Etoile to Apicius and this is despite the fact that I am somewhat of a francophile, having a French uncle, who lives in the Dordogne. It is interesting that Ngaire commented on the lamb, because that was our experience--the lamb was better in L'Etoile than in Apicius.
At the same time, I think it is critical for Radisson to maintain their high standards on the PG precisely because so many of those cruisers are first-time RSSC (we were), and one assumes that Radisson wants (and needs) repeat customers. We enjoyed the PG so much that we went to Alaska on the Mariner and have booked two more RSSC cruises, including the PG in February 06.
Food is very subjective. We actually enjoyed the meals on the PG slightly more than those on the Mariner. However, it seems there is a clear consensus in recent PG reviews of something now lacking in the dining experience, and we hope that situation will be rectified and not indicate a trend.
Eugene