Arlene, I have to agree with you, and thank you for posting, since you were there for the first week, had a great time, and now David completes the reviews for the second week (Pat posted on another thread that everything else was fine) It appears from all the reviews that I have read, that those aboard for the second week only had an issue with that one unfortunate night when L'Etoile got closed. That was really bad. Everything for the rest of the week was fine.

Richard, I suggest that if you go on this cruise in September wondering about every little detail and looking for the negative, you are going to find it. When you called the Sat. night fiasco "criminal" (maybe that was on cc, not here), it alerted me that you are perhaps going to go into this cruise with a forensic mentality. Don't let yourself do so or you will be miserable, and make your wife so as well!

As I remember, you WERE on that Diamond ill-fated cruise where they not only offered free kids, but free booze as well. Room service was choked with both, since unfortunately RSSC did not provide in-room bar set up on that cruise. I remember your complaints on cc. RSSC as since corrected, and we haven't seen such an offer since.

I would not hesitate to book another PG cruise, if I had the time. I am booked so far in advance with my travel that it is almost embarrasing to be so self-indulgent!