|
0 registered members (),
58,841
guests |
|
A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182637
03/12/08 11:02 AM
|
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 334
hrprof
OP
cruiser
|
OP
cruiser
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 334 |
A highly biased comparison – “R†VS. “Oâ€
We have just returned from a 28 day B2B on Oceania Insignia from Valparaiso to Rio. This was our first cruise on O with most of our previous experience on Regent. While cruising has not played a dominant role in our travel, we have sailed on all of the Regent ships past and present. We were looking at the Mariner which did a similar itinerary in January, but we couldn’t get away then. We researched O and based on favorable reports on this site and others along with similarities between the two lines booked O for this cruise.
All cruise reviews are, by definition, biased based on previous experience, preferences, and expectations. Our preferences a bit bizarre, so let’s deal with them!
Space – we put a premium on space. Our Regent experience is based on the larger suites – we booked an OS for both legs of this cruise. Lest anyone think that we are obsessed with being carried around on a pillow, let me add that we travel extensively on Lindblad Expeditions where accommodations are not spacious, cuisine is not Haute, no butlers, no room service, no shows – a different experience with different expectations.
Shows – We don’t often go to shows – 28 days, not one show, so no comment on this.
Lounges – We are not lounge sitters – 28 days, no experience with lounges!
Cuisine – We are not foodies, our day does not revolve around meal time, but we expect food to be well prepared and served.
OK, let’s go.
Logistics – all pre planning and arrangements were flawless with the exception of a large number of itinerary changes on the second leg of the trip (BA-Rio). The inclusion of a stop at Rio Grande, Brazil had no redeeming qualities. Embarkation was a breeze with suite passengers allowed on the ship at 11 AM. No unessential niceties (Champagne and being escorted to room) which R is quite good at. R VS. O? An edge to R. I should add that as a result of bad air arrangements and missed connections a bunch of folks arrived without luggage and were pretty steamed about it. We always do our own air. We did talk to quite a few passengers who rated the cruise highly but would not go with O in the future because of the air problems.
Space – We found the OS on O to be more than adequate. We were on deck six at the stern – 622 sq ft. with a 340 sq ft deck – separate sleeping and living areas – large flat screen TV with Bose sound system, DVD player, fridge, 2 bathrooms, and most comfortable beds ever. Noise at the stern? Yes. A problem? No. Negatives? Bathroom does not have a separate shower. For those of us whose flexibility ain’t what it used to be, leaping the gunwales of a bath tub can be hazardous! For those who read my previous post on the fares of O VS. R on this site, we can’t ignore value. With this in mind, O wins by a landslide!
Service – Simply outstanding! From the Butler to the housekeeper to all Dining room personnel and front line folks at reception, we had nothing but favorable experience. Our experience with service on R has been uniformly outstanding with the exception of one grumpy butler and occasional slow service in Dining Rooms. A slight edge to O on service. One pleasant surprise was an invitation to all those in OS and VS (20 folks) to a private Cocktail party followed by a six course dinner in an area arranged for privacy on the pool deck. Those O repeaters indicated that this was new.
Dining Venues – O has a number of dining choices which parallel those available on R. There are 2 specialty restaurants, a main dining room, a pool deck grill and a buffet which is open for breakfast and lunch. Obviously, personal taste is dominant here, but we rated the two O specialty restaurants, Polo Grill (beef and seafood) and Toscana (Italian) as vastly superior to Latitudes, and Signatures on R. We never cared very much for the Latitudes menu – I think that we went there just once. Since we often have dinner in the suite, we were surprised that we could order from the Specialty restaurant menus as well as the main dining room. Another key difference in all restaurants on O is the number and placement of “two top†tables – there are many and there are lots with window locations. One other difference is the dedication of the buffet restaurant (Terrace) on O to an informal evening buffet. We went there often. A negative? The terrace did become quite crowded at lunch time. However, our preferences favor O on dining venues by a significant margin.
Food – Uh oh! As previously indicated, our day is not ruined if the piquancy of the Béarnaise is not properly calibrated! The food on both lines is outstanding with a very slight edge to R.
The “nickel and diming†debate – A key difference between the two lines is the all inclusive fares on R and the added charges on O. Having to get out the card to charge almost everything on O is a royal pain and, in my opinion, demolishes the warmth and hospitality which O is quite good at creating. We don’t go to lounges, but do like a drink (or two) in the suite before dinner. R always had Wild Turkey in the suite bar on arrival and replaced it when required – even on the Paul Gaugin in French Polynesia! On this cruise, we restocked the bar at port stops – O had no problem with this. Gratuities are automatically added to the bill, although our TA had this waived on the first leg. Outstanding service merited an addition to the standard gratuity amount. We discovered that OS folks did not have to pay for bottled water. The all inclusive concept is a defining difference between the two lines. Clearly, one pays dearly for the all inclusive fares on R. Drinking the difference in cost between the two would require immediate admission to rehab at the conclusion of the cruise assuming that one survived the cruise! So, pay your money and make your choice!
Dumbest thing we did – O ships have “Cabanasâ€. There are 8 of them, top forward, which give a private space with a forward view. These are somewhat controversial because they block off this area from other passengers. Since our cabin was in the stern, we rented one of these for the cruise to give us a forward view – big mistake - $1250 for 47 minutes of occupancy. Oh well, live and learn!
CCC VS. Black tie – R has the traditional dress code array of formal, informal and CCC, while O is CCC throughout the ship. I did the Black Tie thing enough when I was working for a living and view hauling the tux and associated accoutrements as an inconvenience and a bit of an anachronism. We saw no cases of abuse of the dress code and, in fact, saw more jackets at dinner than we expected. I’m with O on this one.
Shore excursions – O has been criticized for expensive and poorly planned excursions. This is a valid criticism. We went on the O Iguacu excursion out of BA – it was expensive and was a bit of a mob scene – the Falls were breathtaking, but for $ 2600 for two for one overnight and be put in a room with no falls view was disappointing. R gets the nod on this one.
Miscellany – I can’t understand the popularity of art auctions on cruise ships – both R and O do these along with most lines. I guess that some folks really like these.
We don’t do shows because our taste in the performing arts leans to ballet, classical music, opera and Broadway. O had a string quartet that played in a venue not intended to be background music, but truly listened to. It was not the Guaneri or the Tokyo, but was very good. Kudos to O for providing this.
Shipboard activities were the usual games, lectures, afternoon tea (we didn’t get to this) dancing etc. No major differences here.
Many of the rooms on O are quite small and not all have outside decks. One must book a Penthouse suite on O to get close to the “basic†suite on R. We would only cruise O in OS or VS, and it is difficult to confirm these suites. A $1000 deposit can tie up a suite for a year until final payment is due, so these suites get bought up in nanoseconds after schedules are published. I would suggest that O increase the deposit and cancellation penalties to insure a higher level of commitment to the initial reservation.
The fellow passengers on O were, with few exceptions, delightful folks. There were many repeats among the complement, and because of the lower fares the group was more diverse than is the case on R. A large number of Brits and Canadians on this cruise.
Bottom line – In terms of value received for the dollar, R gets knocked out of the ring! (Please refer to my fare comparison on this site) Will we desert R and defect to O? No. One reason is the unavailability of the limited suites on O that we would book and we really like the all inclusive concept. But, if we could be assured of getting an OS or VS and be able to somehow pay a supplement which would destroy the charge card……..???
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182638
03/12/08 11:28 AM
|
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,447
Sue&TomInGeorgia
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,447 |
hrprof; while we have not cruised on O, I did enjoy reading your comparison and appreciated it! :)
Sue "A vacation is having nothing to do and all day to do it in" Robert Orben *******
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182639
03/12/08 11:41 AM
|
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 10,095
petlover
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 10,095 |
Ted, Thanks for taking the time to write such an excellent well thought out comparison! We too have considered trying "O" and thinking about the bottom line $$. It may be different in our case as we definitely do lounges and such. Drinking the difference in cost between the two would require immediate admission to rehab at the conclusion of the cruise assuming that one survived the cruise Maybe you had Tom and me in mind (and a few other LCTers) :D That's what great about cruising...something that appeals to everyone
Marcie
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182640
03/12/08 01:17 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 6,370
Marc
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 6,370 |
I would be interested in the assessment of cost (i.e., value) comparing the Oceania OS to the Voyager or Mariner Cat H. I have always believed that the best value for me is on a ship where the cheapest accomodations are up to my standards; of course, this includes food, service, amenities, etc. in the definition "up to my standards." In this situation, others are subsidizing your enjoyment of the rest of the ship.
Many have said that the Oceania PH is a good comparison to the Regent Cat H; however, here you are subsidizing others. Also, I understand that the Oceania PH doesn't have some of the benefits mentioned in your review.
It will be interesting to see how Oceania versus Regent play out over time as part of PCH. They have stated that they are keeping the two lines separate as they focus on different portions of the market. If the customers do not feel that there is a difference, then it is harder for the company to charge two different price points.
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182641
03/12/08 02:34 PM
|
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 240
Island Cruiser
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 240 |
The only thing about your excellent and detailed review I don't get is the "highly biased" label. You identified variables that are important to you and those than aren't and then offered cogent commentary. Thanks so much, Ted. We too have looked at O and asked ourselves "Whould it be too much of a let down?" I think you are saying something like "Not at all." That is indeed good news. IMO it is great to have good cruising alternatives. Pat
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182642
03/12/08 08:48 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 7,646
ChatKat...
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 7,646 |
As someone who has done both R and O - I think your assessment is right on target. I would do either one based on the itinerary, price and timing. We booked O for the Baltics. 14 days instead of 7 for the same fare and more ports. Concierge Class so the room is the same as the PG as opposed to G on Voyager. There were several things we liked better than R and some better on R over O. Just like cruising the mass market lines, sometimes you might need to have an alternative means of travel. Variety is the spice of life.
VOYAGER: MC to FLL 11/07 MC/Dover 6/06 MARINER: BCN / Ven 10/11 Alaska 2001|2006 Panama Canal 2003 NAV Caribbean 11/06 Bermuda|New Eng/Canada 6/04 PG 5/05 OCEANIA Nautica |Ist/Athens 6/07 Regatta|Baltics 6/08 Riviera 2013 Crossing -Istanbul to Miami
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182643
03/13/08 01:47 AM
|
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,415
Wandra
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,415 |
I read your review, and I was happy to see it, especially since we're exploring that itinerary for the future.
I will never book an OS, however, so their being so scarce wouldn't bother me. I'd be content with a PH, or even an A (not below that.) Marc, why would you want to base the comparison on an OS, and not a PH, since the PH approximates the size of an H?
I too am interested to hear what amenities or perks you had being in an OS, that other passengers didn't receive. You mentioned water, but I wonder if you were treated differently.
Wendy ------ Booked: Uniworld Egypt, 2015 Tauck Amsterdam to Budapest, 2016 Paul Gauguin, Societies & Tuamotus 2016
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182644
03/13/08 02:59 AM
|
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 1,732
ColonelWes
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 1,732 |
Ted, great to hear you had a super cruise that in general lived up to your expectations..thanks for taking the time and sharing an outstanding comparative review...r/wes
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182645
03/13/08 02:59 AM
|
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 6,370
Marc
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 6,370 |
Originally posted by Wandra: I will never book an OS, however, so their being so scarce wouldn't bother me. I'd be content with a PH, or even an A (not below that.) Marc, why would you want to base the comparison on an OS, and not a PH, since the PH approximates the size of an H?
I too am interested to hear what amenities or perks you had being in an OS, that other passengers didn't receive. You mentioned water, but I wonder if you were treated differently. Wendy, if the amenities for suite passengers on Oceania are higher than amenities for a PH or CC cabin, then I think that comparing Regent Cat H to a PH or CC would be wrong.
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182646
03/13/08 03:18 AM
|
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,434
Dreps
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,434 |
Marc, I too, don't understand the point you are making. We booked a PH3 on a Rio to Valparaiso cruise for next February, believing that we wouldn't be happy in the standard room. The only thing I don't like about the PH is that you can't separate it into two areas. (This is nice when I wake up early and work on pictures and compose e-mails on the computer before Gail is awake.) Therefore, I am very heartened by Ted's review. As I told Marcie, we are paying about $377 per person per day for the 19-day cruise (including fuel surcharge, port tax, and BK awards), but not including air, which we will arrange ourselves. That seems pretty good to me. We just don't drink enough to come close to making up the difference in Regent's price, if they were doing this itinerary. The major thing I will miss is the free internet, and I certainly agree that signing for everything is a pain, but we'll just have to adapt.
-----------------
Eugene
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182647
03/13/08 03:35 AM
|
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 306
AndreaRH
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 306 |
Ted,
Thanks so much for this great review! We've been looking at O because they've got some great itineraries at good price points. Since I don't drink alcohol, the all-inclusive nature of R isn't so much a draw for me (although Len loves it!).
How was the space ratio onboard? Did the ship feel comfortable and spacious? That's what we love about the Mariner, plenty of room in the public areas...it never feels crowded.
Andrea
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182648
03/13/08 05:28 AM
|
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,415
Wandra
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,415 |
Marc, I hear what you're saying, but I believe it's called a "Penthouse Suite".
I agree about the classical music. Although our musical tastes are eclectic, it would be great to have some really good classical performances (we had this one on Diamond.)
How "bouncy" was the ship? And spacious? The specialty restaurants sounds wonderful. So does the CCC dress code, and the passenger diversity.
Wendy ------ Booked: Uniworld Egypt, 2015 Tauck Amsterdam to Budapest, 2016 Paul Gauguin, Societies & Tuamotus 2016
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182649
03/13/08 12:11 PM
|
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 934
RPM
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 934 |
I went on an O cruise with my classmate from Miami to LA. Loved the ship and the people we met. Stayed in a concierge cabin "A" I think and found it small due to the fact we had the beds in a twin configeration.Closet space was fine,movies on TV were really good . HOWEVER,the amount of rock and roll motion was heavy.Said at the time didnt know if Ray could handle it. It didnt bother me at all. The entertainment was very low key,but for some reason I really enjoyed it,perhaps because it was more intimate. Best trivia I ever had on ANY cruise ship...loads of fun with awesome questions. The tours left a bit to be desired...not bad but not great either , had worse ones on HAL. Laundry rooms used "tokens" which you purchased at reception, but hey at least they had them. Can't remember if there was dancing as Ray wasn't there. Small cosy bars with expensive drinks...about $11.00 or $12.00 US for a martini,Grey Goose more...good wine list with reasonable prices which they would keep from one night to another. Where O was the greatest was the food.Whether in the main dining room or on the Veranda ,called "Tapas" I think. We ate there many nights, homemade ice-cream,yum yum.The two alternative restaurants were superb!! Much better than Regents and for that matter Crystals. The wait staff tended towards Eastern Europeans and I believe Philappinos...very nice and friendly. Ok just wanted to put my two cents in about O. I really enjoyed it and would certainly return there,if the seas were quiet,lol. 
Pat and Ray
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182650
03/13/08 03:25 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 140
billp1
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 140 |
It is amazing how we all see things so differently. We like our wine and our before dinner cocktails. Not signing a check for everything we order even though I probably paid via a higher cruise fare to me is worth cruising on Regent or Silversea.
Less people and larger cabins also count for us...
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182651
03/13/08 05:19 PM
|
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 474
Yallcruise
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 474 |
My only problem with O is the bathrooms. Way to small for two people. No were to store anything. Everything else is fine. Regents bathrooms are the nicest ship bathrooms I have ever seen.
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182652
03/13/08 07:10 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 7,646
ChatKat...
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 7,646 |
The comparison for a PH on O is most appropriate to a Cat H on Regent. The amenities and cabin size are comparable except for beverages and tips. Actually in a PH on O, you get a Butler which you do not get on R in the H category. If you are an SSS member, you do not get those benefits. But for the price differential to pay for internet or telephone and tips was still worthwhile. The bathrooms on R are hard to match at sea but are not a deal breaker either. Tub over shower and adequate sink - but for one at a time.
VOYAGER: MC to FLL 11/07 MC/Dover 6/06 MARINER: BCN / Ven 10/11 Alaska 2001|2006 Panama Canal 2003 NAV Caribbean 11/06 Bermuda|New Eng/Canada 6/04 PG 5/05 OCEANIA Nautica |Ist/Athens 6/07 Regatta|Baltics 6/08 Riviera 2013 Crossing -Istanbul to Miami
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182653
03/15/08 02:04 PM
|
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 637
Tom G
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 637 |
Great comparison Ted. I especially liked your observations on "nickel and diming." Most people, including me, really hate nickel and diming. But we pay dearly for the privilege of not being nickel and dimed.
You can charge people $1000 up front for $500 worth of goods and services and they will be happier than if they had to pay only $500 but had to pay it in drips and drabs. Tom.
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182654
03/15/08 03:37 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,387
Jim B
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,387 |
I would say that I would have to agree with you Tom in the past, but with the way prices are going up it makes you wonder.
|
|
|
Re: A highly biased comparison R vs. O
#182655
03/15/08 07:40 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 672
FDV72
cruiser
|
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 672 |
I would agree with you Tom that the consumer does think like that a lot of the time. For me I just never had a problem presenting my cruise card for things, I mean you have to carry it anyway, to get on and off the ship and to get into your stateroom. If you need it to pay for drinks or water, it just doesnt seem like a big deal to me. I mean if your staying at a Ritz Carlton or Four Seasons you need to sign for things. Regarding Oceania I would not have a problem paying $3.50 for a big bottle of Evian in my room, when it costs $2.50 at your local Walgreens.
FV
|
|
|
|
|
|