I agree that food is enormously subjective, which is further complicated by the fact that most restaurants tend to vary to some degree from night to night. On our two Voyager cruises, we had our best meals in Signature, although we loved Compass Rose. We found the food at Latitudes to be presented beautifully (about the coolest plates one could imagine for each course - it was not a small matter for me to smuggle a set for eight off the ship in my hand luggage!!) but not at all memorable from a gustatory (such a word, no??) standpoint. Talk about form over culinary substance!!
On our recent B2B on the PG, we found the meals at Apicius to be generally the best we had - three of the four times we ate there the meal was quite good. Two of our three best lamb dishes on the PG were served to us at Apicius. And Apicius from time to time served up a genuinelly inspired dish, such as the excellent wild mushroom risotto, which we had as a dish somewhere in the meal at each of our four meals at that venue.
All this being stated, I, too, am a bit apprehensive about a conversion of the evening version of La Veranda from Apicius to a "French bistro" menu. If they manage to do a genuine French bisto menu, with dishes such as a simple but perfectly roasted chicken, grilled steak with frites, calf's liver with shallots, etc., the restaurant may be a worthy substitute for Apicius and a bit more approachable for people with less adventuresome tastes. But, in fact, Apicius' menu had a reasonable number of choices, including dishes that were quite straightforward and not at all intimidating. But if all they do is change from sophisticated French dishes to cheaper but not well-made "bistro" fare, that will not be a change for the better in any sense. Good bistro fare must be something far superior to the lunch buffet offerings. I think that at the end of the day, the question will be: Is this new menu one based on a high quality offering of a different sort of cuisine (Yea!!), or is it based merely on costs savings (Boo!!)? We await the reports of future passengers eagerly.
I concur with Dreps that RSSC (is it still "Radisson SSC" or has it changed already to "Regent SSC") should make every effort to cultivate repeat customers on its higher end ships by giving them a remarkable experience on the PG, which tends to get more first timers. Unless RSSC is very careful, it risks the quality degenerating to the point that the food will be considered less than high end in absolute terms, even for passengers who have not experienced the clearly superior cuisine on the other RSSC ships. In that case, RSSC will have the dreadful problem of former PG passengers who think that all the RSSC ships will have mediocre grub. Not a pleasant prospect. So, RSSC corporate lurkers, be warned that the food police are on patrol and that food issues on the PG will continue to generate loads of comment, speculation, gossip, and general mind churn. All of that energy would be much better used in threads about the glories of the ships and their itineraries. (But as for me, food talk will remain a most magnetic subject.) Cheers, Fred