We haven't seen any gaps in Silversea service on 4 cruises in two years, but enough people mentioned it on Camel that I do have some concerns even though I have sailed on Shadow recently. They have a very, very good training program. One thing I do remember on one or two of the cruises is officers jumping in the lunch line in front of guests fairly agressively. I did find this to be a turnoff.

I have only done two Regent cruises, but both were in the last 10 months. I found many of the issues mentioned, and all were disappointing to me, but I still had fabulous cruises that were some of the best times I have had in recent years. I also found the food imaginative and creative in many cases on Regent, though I do agree sometimes there were not enough soup and appetizer choices. I think they need to polish up the service. We go at Christmas, and it will be my husband's first time on Regent, so I am looking forward to hearing his comparisons. I didn't sail on Radisson, but I am guessing some of the things I see needing polished may be transition issues. I think the trainers need to sail the competition (all luxury lines I am sure have staff sailing each other, but maybe not the staff training people??). Just a thought.

Though I am often an SS cheerleader, if in April, they lapse, I will tell it!