I have a suggestion for everyone.

One of the reasons Crystal does excel in good service is the fixed seating dining. You sit at the same table every night at exactly the same time with the same waiters. That really helps on the service end of things. The waiters get to know you and your likes and dislikes. If you always order a particular drink for instance - then it just "comes". The tables are all pretty much at the same stage in the dining courses, that helps the waiters. A relationship develops with the waiters, they get to know and you get to know them.

Fixed seating dining offers these advantages.

However for me, open seating dining is something I will never give up, but there are issues with open seating dining.

On Regent and Silversea you sit in different areas with different waiters who have not learned your likes and dislikes. Also all the tables are at different stages in dining. We arrive at different times. Really nice for the guests but harder for the waiters.

If you find a waiter you like then request his table each night. He will get to know you and you get to know him, then you will find your experience is enhanced.

Regent and Silversea will not hold tables for people to be fair to all concerned so if you like a waiter and table you need in the dining room before that table is taken.

On Camel, Silversea, Olivia found a waiter and table location she liked and she was at that dining room the minute it opened "holding her table". It was her "home" for each night and the guests at her table just changed. They had a wonderful relationship with their waiter and the whole dining experience was definitely enhanced.

I sat in "Olivia's area" and found the service to be excellent. I moved to another area on two nights as we were late and no tables were available. We had the same surly waiter both times who told me "there were no berries and would not be for the rest of the cruise". I think he just did not want to bother with a special order. Next night no problem berries on request.

These are big dining rooms. Some waiters will be better than others. True in anything there are always people better at their job than others.

Find your "waiter" stick with him if possible. As you change dining companions (one of the absolute joys of open seating in my view) it may not always be possible but just a suggestion to enhance your cruise experience.