On our last 5 cruises on Regent I would have to say that all met or exceeded our expectations, except for our Dec 7th 2007 cruise, in which we felt that service was lacking a bit. The only answer I can give is a large portion of the staff was getting off the ship at the end of the cruise and maybe that contributed to it. It was really only in CR that we had a few issues with getting wine and our Stateroom attendant trying to rush us out of our room early so she could start her vacation.
In terms of price I feel there should be no lack of any type of service since there prices had basically doubled in the last five years and going all-inclusive really did not cost them that much extra and they are charging a PREMIUM for it.
I would agree with Count Florida that you can get some good deals on Princess: we have sailed them a couple of times, of course you get what you pay for. In my opinion unless you are eating in the alternative venues or its formal night in the main dining room, the food at dinner is very bland and the presentation is something that resembles a TV dinner on my plate: and usually tastes like it also.
Just My opinion though!
FV