We were on the Mariner in June and found service just fine with an almost full ship. I do notice on nights when almost everyone arrives at the same time it does put stress on the wait staff. We sailed Crystal several times but not recently since we hated the set seating and having the same table mates which was sometimes great and sometimes less than stimulating. They do a great job on dining service but again you are comparing apples and oranges. It's much easier for a wait staff to personalize service if they see the same people for each meal and can get to know their likes and dislikes. On Regent they have a new group of people each night. On one cruise where there were 8 of us and we sat at the same table each night we did get more personalized servce. I know that some people have favorite waiters and they will try to accomadate you to sit at their tables.