Sounds like the cc thread has been hi-jacked by Crystal-ites. We've never sailed on Crystal but as I understand it, it has a very different ethos - more formal (stuffy?) perhaps but different for certain than Regent.
We've spent alot of time on the Voyager - has everything been perfect all the time? No. Has every staff member been perfect? No. Has every meal been wonderful? No but most are very good and if it doesn't suit - order something else.
But having said all of this, NONE of what has been said - not offered a choice of wine, the length of time to get a hamburger by the pool or a drink at a bar, rude replies etc every happened? Not once. or at least not to us.
We like the no tipping policy and feel the staff does as well. They get paid decent salaries and we as passengers have never felt that we are being fawned over to get us to cough up a few more dollars. Having said that, we contribute to the crew fund since the fund helps staff at all levels, not just the people we see but the ones we don't, who work just as hard!
/getting off my soap box.
Peggy
editing to add: We have always felt the service on Regent has been excellent.