I'm with Donna and Suzie, Frank and I too like the dressy nights, as we rarely get to dress up anymore. It does make me feel more special. Although, I could see and agree with maybe going all CCC on 7 night cruises.
When we were on Oceania, it was all CCC and I was amazed on the Captains welcome and farewell nights that people really dressed up, men were in suits and women in very nice dresses. We actually were more casual, Frank didn't even take a tie, which is unusual for him.