sassy, I think you will find that many others who have tried the lines you have mentioned say the same thing! You can interchange the comments about cabins between Silversea and Regent's larger three ships, they are almost identical, except for the bathrooms in Mariner, most of which have a rather awkward tub/shower for tall people, rather than tub & separate shower. The points you made about Crystal are exactly the same ones that keep me away from Crystal, as well as the fact it is not all-inclusive at even higher prices than Regent.