The hotels change and not guaranteed to be the ones on the list on the web or that may show up on a guest reservation early on. They reserve the right to make a substitue and often that happens. A hotel fills and they have to find another one or they simply decide to use a different hotel. If they have complaints I know they change. It is all subject to change! You just get what you are given when you do the included night.
If you are platinum and using RSSC air and want to come in a day early you do not have air deviation fee and unless there is a LONG expensive transfer you are better off doing your own hotel.
If you are NOT Platinum and are doing RSSC air and have to pay the air deviation fee of $125 pp each or $250 for to come in a day early then the situation is not as clear. The price you get direct with the hotel you have to consider that $250 cost and the transfer costs as well. Also remember to confirm your own rate includes taxes and breakfast.
If you are doing your OWN air then most of the time you should just do your own hotel.
If you can use points you should do your own hotel.
LONG transfers for instance London to Southampton change the dynamics as to buy that transfer is pretty expensive then the RSSC hotel program is probably best for everyone.