Richard,
I hope to post from the PG. I have to go by Marcie's recent 108 days and JoAnna and Olivia's finding things perfectly acceptable. Wes' raving review is recent. There are many more here that will agree that they have all had good experiences.
I think there are a few isolated incidents being blown out of preportion on the other board by a few who do not understand that RSSC is not the owner of the PG and those who want some attention. The Diamond cancellation issue was perhaps a bad decision on how the contract read - but again that was probably signed years ago. I don't think that there is a huge issue. There was a lot of lead time for those passengers and there was compensation.
Just my two cents worth.