Richard,
Those are the same comments (poor English, not well trained) made about the Diamond when she got all an all new serving staff several years ago. I think that particular ships serving staff turned out to be one of the best in the fleet, after their intitial "training" period.

I am not saying that the poster you are referring to is unreliable, all I am saying is what he encountered with a new staff should be expected, it was just his bad luck to get such a green staff.

Editing to add, I was on the Diamond 4 weeks after the big staff change years ago. When I came home, I read the review from the man who was on the first weeks sailing after the change and he was in an uproar over how terrible the service was.
Had I not read his review, I would of had no idea that there even was a staff change as they all were exceptional servers by the time my sailing rolled around.


Karen

Live long and prosper