Too bad Don's cruising ... he'd be the best person to ask about the SS experience since he loves it so much. And I'm not sure where Olivia is. But from what they've said about it, I don't think stuffy is a word that they would use to describe SS. Ngaire herself has said that RSSC and SS are VERY similar in some ways ... even some of their ships look similar (built in the same shipyard). Besides SS being inclusive in terms of liquor and minor differences in cuisine, they're actually fairly similar products. I think you'd be happy on either if you found the right cruise at the right price.

Masaki