Part 1, the ship, the staff, service, food
If I had to choose a single word for this cruise experience, it would be "extraordinary". Not to say that any trip on the Paul Gauguin would be "ordinary", but this one was special. Probably as special as our first trip on her in 2000. In most ways the practical aspects of this cruise equalled or exceeded that first trip.
We were blown away by the service, foremost. The staff, including the crew, hotel staff and wait/cabin staff were all on the top of their games. I was a bit apprehensive about this, having witnessed low staff morale in June of 2005 after the Grand Circle purchase created a lot of uncertainty about the future of the ship and its employees. No sign of any of that, despite the announced withdrawal of Regent in 2010. It's my guess that the staff believe they will either continue to have jobs on the PG, or will find jobs on other Regent ships.
The food was great. With a couple of forgivable exceptions, L'Etoile was great, and often amazing. Le Grill was much better than last time, and La Veranda still is a very nice dining experience. By the end of the cruise we were feeling like blimps and skipping the odd meal, we just couldn't cope.
In general, fish was excellent, meats were great, the variety was very good.
The Staff
As I said, the staff were all very attentive and seemed happy and productive. I am missing having my napkin unfolded on my lap, my plate carried, and my wine glass filled.
The staff who stood out for us:
Engelbert (hotel manager), Martha Hanley (guest relations), Craig (maitre'd of La Verandah), Francisco at the Pool Bar, Jorge (George) and Michael in L'Etoile, and our two tireless stewardesses (April and Rhea) who, instead of throwing out everything placed even close to our vanity wastebasket, retrieved things from the basket that they thought we had put in there by mistake (err on the side of caution.)
Phil Butterworth, the travel concierge manager was really great at his job, and quite charming; he is heading for the world cruise--you WC'ers are in for a treat there. I'm wondering if he was sent to beef up this operation on the PG after complaints in recent months.
And of course, Arnold, who was maitre'd of Le Grill. He seemed quiet when we first boarded, but was his old self within a few days--I think he was probably worried about his vacation, since he didn't know if he was going home on the 20th at the end of our cruise, until the day before. He was on our flight back to LA.
Everybody was great. I continue to be in awe of how hard these people work.
Overall Condition
The ship was in fine form, despite going into dry dock in January.
On the subject of mildewy smells, something that has been brought up repeatedly on both forums: yes, there is a mildewy smell in the halls and stairways. It's mostly fairly subdued, and I remember that smell from the year 2000!. Yes, it's always been there. I admit it was pretty heavy in the deck 7 corridors, so hopefully they will change those carpets during the drydock. But for me, the smell is part of the PG. Go figure!
The carpets generally look fine, although they have that "brushed the wrong way" look that many carpets on all the ships seem to develop. In general the ship looked its usual fabulous and upkeep was ongoing in the wee small hours by the guys we call the "umpa lumpas", the maintenance crew.
Dining:
L'Etoile
At its best, although the dessert called the "Bounty" is no more. Dinners were mostly wonderful, although the first night was just okay (normal on the first night). As usual I can't come up with a litany of what I ate, and will have forgotten all the details in another week or two. But some really amazing stuff. All beautifully presented and served. A couple of minor service glitches during the 14 days.
Buffet meals on disembarkation day were just okay, but that's fairly normal.
La Veranda
We had two dinners there, and they were great. The menu changes every week so we had a different menu on our second visit, but both menus had sufficient options to keep diners happy for multiple visits. The last night there David and I split entrees, a mushroom risotto and some type of fancy entrecote, both yummy.
Le Grill
Interesting and wonderful Polynesian and Asian fusion food. Nicely prepared and presented. Service was terrific, partly thanks to Arnold at the helm as maitre'd. Ambience was very nice, I'd forgotten how romantic it is. Much improved from last time.
Wine
Wine was good most of the time. Sometimes very good, once in a while just so-so. Californian, New Zealand, Australian, French, Chilean. I can't really comment on whether the wine selections are worse than previous, they were fine with me. Fewer Californian wines I think.
Breakfast and Lunch
We alternated between Le Grill and Le Veranda for breakfast and lunch, depending on the weather. I love to eat outside, but often the calm and cool of the internal dining room prevailed, especially since the weather was fairly hot, particularly when anchored. Lunch buffet is the same in both places, and were mostly themed. These were very nicely done; particularly liking the German, Polynesian and Italian days. David frequently had his Eggs Bennie in La Veranda for brekkies, and always his corned beef hash. Of course, La Veranda continues to have its a la carte menu, rather short, but adequate.
And of course there was the "breakfast club", La Palette for coffee and croissants in the early morning. A band of regulars who got to know each other over the two weeks, reading their little newspaper flyers and watching sunrises and sail-ins.
Cabin specifics
We were in a B Verandah cabin this time. Nice. Same bathroom and cupboard layout as the standard cabins. King sized bed, more room around the vanity, full-sized love-seat and easy chair in the larger living room area. Nice verandah, deeper than standard. Only complaint was I wish they had reclinable deck chairs. Anichini sheets (amazing, I want some!) and bathroom products (the Regent products were supplied as well.) We had a team of two room stewardesses who did the whole corridor of deck 8 (18 cabins)--not sure how the regular rooms were handled.
Flat screen TV, ipod dock (not great, certainly not Bose.)
Having a butler was interesting, although we didn't use him much. We found it easier to make restaurant ressies with the maitre'd's because then we could make decision on the spot depending on what was available. We got our daily canapes, although after a few days it was a bit much--too much food everywhere!! Our friend Jim across the hall used his butler, Abner, a lot, and he quite enjoyed having this service (now he's spoiled forever.)
The Boutique
Lots of beautiful pearls, as usual. This gift shop has the advantage of a single year-round destination, so they can stock things that people will want in a tropical paradise. The concession is run entirely by Tahia Collins now, so some things have changed. For example, the room right at the back on the left which used to be full of expensive perfume is now full of flip flops and crocs. An improvement as far as I'm concerned, but they had run low on sizes. Lots of nice men's shirts (Jim bought a couple), hats, t-shirts, skirts, pareos, etc. The pareo selection got completely cleaned out during the 2 weeks. I loved prowling around in there on sea days to ogle the pears (but didn't buy any.)
The bars:
The new Piano Bar is a huge improvement. It's like the Navigator Lounge (think I've got that right), but better, more open. A real gathering spot before and after dinner. La Palette is also nice, and host to lots of events, and is the late-night disco (although we never made it, Jim did!) And the pool bar, the old standby, it too has improved with the roof "wings" that have been added on both sides fore on the pooldeck for shade.
All the lounges were heavily used. Only a couple of real drunks on board, although certain people who will remain nameless sat almost motionless in a chair on the motu after a late night in La Palette.
Entertainment
The Gauguines, as ever, were great and did several really nice shows. Their presence is one of the great touches on this ship. And although we missed Hal Fraser, Bruce (Tildon), did a great job as the piano-man, despite getting laryngitis halfway through the trip. Kudos to him.
The band was fairly uniformly awful. My son, the struggling musician is buoyed by this information. Any of the bar performers that we see regularly here in Toronto could blow these babies out of the water. The "Skyline" band were all young, and perhaps decent musicians (except the drummer who was dreadful), but they had obviously been thrown together, and had not rehearsed much. They were fronted by a girl singer, who had not a bad voice, especially when she sang soul music--she certainly deserved a better backup band. The one time they did a creditable job together was in our amazing sail past Taha'a, with the setting sun shining on the island. This was magical and the band on the pool deck managed to capture this. So Siglo was sadly missed, not a perfect band, but very versatile (although if they neveer play another Queen song it will be too soon.)
Heather Kreuzman, who was a Social Hostess also performed, and did two shows, and although her voice isn't bad, it's not good enough to fill the Grand Salon, and I left after a few songs. Or maybe I just didn't like that sort of music.
They had a (somewhat fading) opera diva on board, and although we did not go, Jim did, and although he enjoyed the Edit Piaf evening, the opera evening was less successful.
Two great folkoric shows--the standard O Tahiti E on the last night, and a great troupe on Bora Bora.
All in all, then, the entertainment was spotty, and fairly disappointing.
Oh, one great counterexample--the Liars' Club. They did two of these and they were very funny and entertaining. They should do this on all the ships during long voyages--David and Jim are going to try to get one organized at the Faculty Club here.
Lectures
Mark Eddoes was absent. That pretty well says it all for anyone who has been on the PG with him. Fortunately I had not talked him up a lot to Jim, so he wasn't disappointed. I missed his lectures on the Polynesian culture and history. They had their art historian on, the Paul Gauguin expert, and although I learned something about his life and painting, I found her insufferable. Sorry, just my opinion. Lucky her for getting such a great gig.
Denis Schneider, the dashing and handsome French marine biologist from Bora Bora also lectured. We had been previously on his Coral Preservation trip, so knew about him. He talked about, get this, coral preservation. It was very interesting and he is a very engaging fellow.
Shipboard games, diversions
We had fun playing "name that tune" (our group won). The pooldeck fair that they put on during a sea day was noisy and hot, so we demured. At sunset, one main diversion for lots of folks was watching for the "green flash". Captain Zupan (what a guy!), worked at trying to arrange this. One day we witnessed it dipping behind a clear horizon. Later, he tried again, but seeing he was going to fail, turned the ship so that we were facing dead on to Bora Bora as the sun set behind the island. Amazing.
They need a new jigsaw puzzle. About 10 days in, the ol' puzzle was completely stalled, and a little girl, seeing it lying out thought she would be tidy and dumped it back in the box. Good riddance.
We got invited to the bridge for a private sailaway party sailing out the gap at Rangiroa. Although we failed to see the dolphins (saw their splashes sometimes), that was fun. The guest relations officer, Martha Hanley, was fun to talk to, and the guys hung around the instruments, natch. Again, Captain Zupan is a lot of fun, a real riot. We didn't eat with any officers--we turned down an invite because we were travelling with Jim and he didn't get invited.
The weather was amazing. It's the best time of year to go to the Marquesas, and they delivered on this promise--apparently the ship can tender into Fatu Hiva only 30% of the time. One island was a little choppy, and the captain had to move the ship. But we had really only three rainfalls: late night in Papeete before sailaway; a downpour at the Arboretum on Ua Huka; and a brief lingering drizzle on motu mahana--a little welcome shade in a lovely day. The Societies were definitely hotter and muggier than I'm used to--the Marquesas about the same, but presumably it's hotter at other times of the year. It was plenty hot and humid, that's for sure. Sun avoidance was the name of the game.
More later, on people and the itinerary.