Thanks for your review of all of these.
We are very anxious to try RSSC and even more so after your review. We are booked for next August on the MUSH to Alaska cruise and really looking forward to going with our LTC friends.
It also confirms with us that Crystal probably is not the line for us. We do prefer the smaller ships, can't stand assigned seating for dinner, and hate signing for drinks all the time. I am sure that they have over the top service, but these other items are deal killers for us.
We have been on both Seabourn as well as Silversea and loved both. We found the staff on both very accomodating though we thought it a little better on Silversea. We did not experience the same standoffish attitude on either of our Silver Whisper cruises that you experienced. Quite the contrary. On our Caribbean cruise, Captain Casaro as well as the rest of the staff were always mingling with all of the passengers. One time in particular, the Captain asked if he could join the two of us at our table outside of the Terrace Cafe and he just sat down and chatted with us for quite some time. He was very personable. We also found Captain Tatulli and his staff during our Med cruise to be very good in mixing with the clientele. We did found our Legend cruise to be a little stuffier, but it may have just been us, since that was our first luxury cruise experience.
Another line that I would like to experience at some point would be SeaDream. More casual, but still all inclusive and very luxurious. I just wish they had larger cabins.