In most cases on all ships they are selling the guarantees right after a category sells out, this is H, G, F, E etc. Only a few cabins in each category. Timing is pretty difficult though you have to "hit" it just right. They cannot just be bought because you want one the category MUST BE SOLD out first. Sometimes at 9.00 am there is a guarantee available but you call back at 10.30 it is gone.

Then once you get a guarantee you are still most likely now to end up in that category. I think the best thing about guarantees now is that they allow you to book a category that you want if it is already sold out. You want to go on a trip but the least expensive category left is D for cabin assignment but you might get a G or F guarantee instead. Locking in the lower price even though all the cabins are sold. That is the advantage now not the chance of the upgrade.