Less than they used to be. The situation is constantly changing but based on my observations this is how I see it now. I am not saying this is always the way it is as it varies from ship to ship and date to date depending on the volume of bookings and many other factors.

It used to be the guarantees stayed until close to cruise date and then were assigned, usually resulting in an upgrade. Now from what I can tell they are using them as a "waitlist" for the category you are guaranteed in. So if you are in a deck 7 sitting guarantee and one pops open for that time frame you may find yourself assigned very early and in the 7 Sitting cabin. That being said there are only four 7s cabins so the likelihood is that you will get an 8 sitting cabin, particularly on a 3 segment voyage.

The guarantees used to be really a great purchase with excellent odds of an upgrade. Now they are not as desirable as your odds of an upgrade are diminished and you have no choice of your cabin location.

They sell guarantees two ways. Once a category is full they sell a few guarantees(depends on cruise and category) that will be basically a waitlist as they know a certain number of cabins will cancel. They also sell guarantees if they need to promote a sailing so they can sell at the lower prices. Then there are more guarantees to fill so odds of an upgrade are better.

In many ways this is fairer as I think when people pay for a specific category and someone else pays minimum rate and winds up "next door" that does not feel quite right.

When you book a category you do get to select the area the cabin is located in and with a guarantee you "take your chances". Since a guarantee in most situations will end up in the cabin you purchased and you cannot select the location of the cabin. Also often the cabins left over for assignment of the guarantees are the cabins that did not sell - hence often not is such good locations. I am not as fond of the guarantees now as I used to be.

In your case with a 3 segment voyage you got a great rate with a deck 7 sitting room and I think it will work out fine for you.