Just found this board today....

We left (for the most part) the mass market lines this past year when we sailed Crystal for the first time. We've yet to sail RSSC, Silversea or Seabourn, but are on the lookout for something on these lines that catches our eyes.

Although just a one time Crystal cruiser, we do have our second voyage booked in March 2005. I would like to make some observations about all inclusiveness that will hopefully separate Crystal from the mass market lines.

First, we had the lowest shipboard tab at the end of the voyage compared to any previous cruise of equal length on the mass market lines. True, it would have been lower yet if we had sailed RSSC, Silversea or Seabourn. But there were many pre-dinner events where cocktails (whatever you desire) were served complimentary. In addition to both the Captain's Welcome AND Farewell parties, there was also a party held for first time Crystal cruisers.

Second, all stateroom minibars are supplied with sodas, bottled waters and juices, which are replenished throughout the voyage. All complimentary.

Third, all specialty coffees are complimentary in Crystal's wonderful bistro, as well as in any of the lounges or dining room.

Fourth, as to gratuities, we learned after our first voyage that there are several Travel Agents which offer prepaid gratuities for their Crystal clients. For our next sailing, we have confirmed prepaid gratuities, a generous shipboard credit, as well as a $400 gift card because we're paying w/Mastercard. The shipboard credit and Mastercard kickback will sufficiently cover the cost of a moderately priced bottle of wine each evening in the dining room.

There is no denying RSSC, Silversea & Seabourn are all-inclusive compared to Crystal. But I think classifying Crystal as a 'nickel and dime' experience is quite a stretch, at least from our personal experience.

Really enjoying exploring this board. Keep up the great work!