Wendy:
Navigator 4
Mariner 9
Voyager 21
All:
I need some help. We are looking at two alternative Caribbean itineraries: 11 Days on Navigator or two seven day cruises back to back on Voyager returning to FLL in the middle. Here is my analysis:
Date Navigator Voyager
20 Nov Sails FLL Sails FLL
21 Nov Princess Cay Princess Cay (None of us have been....beach day)
22 Nov At sea At sea
23 Nov San Juan San Juan
24 Nov St Thomas St Thomas
25 Nov Dominica Grand Turk (Dominica is new port for all of us; Grand Turk on both itins)
26 Nov St Maarten At sea
27 Nov St Barts FLL (St Barts is new port for all of us)
28 Nov Tortola Key West (Tortola is new port for all of us; we were all in Key West in 02)
29 Nov Grand Turk Cozumel (it was real windy when we went to cozumel, didn't do anything)
30 Nov At sea Cozumel (overnight in cozumel allows plenty of time
01 Dec FLL Belize (New port for all of us)
02 Dec ---- Costa Maya (new port for all of us)
03 Dec ---- At sea
04 Dec ---- FLL
Navigator gives us new ports of Princess Cay, Dominica, St Barts, Tortola, and Grand Turk
Voyager gives us new ports of Princess Cay, Grand Turk, Belize, and Costa Maya (and more time in Cozumel)
Navigator gives us two sea days.
Voyager gives us two sea days plus day in FLL in middle.
In addition, some of the port visits are short so they are almost like sea days on both itineraries.
_____________________________
Navigator does not have a signatures or latitudes. They have an Italian restaurant upstairs that alternates between steakhouse and trattoria. The cabins are same as on Voyager except that bottom two categories do not have balconies. You need to book Cat F to get balcony. Navigator is smaller with max 490 pax. Computer room on Navigator is smaller than Voyager.
I think I priced out Voyager for $4845 for Cat H and $3800 for Navigator Cat F.
______________
On alternating days, I can talk myself into both options. I think Navigator is better cruise because of ports and not sailing back to FLL in middle. Voyager is better since we can check out the ancient ruins in Mexico and Belize. Voyager you get three more days on the ship for one more vacation day.
How does this analysis sound? Did I forget something critical? Which ship would you take?
thanks