We've been on all three, and this is a tough choice. The Mariner and Voyager are not "sisters" but are darn close. The Voyager has larger suites, while the Mariner seems to have more space in public areas. Both are great 700 guest ships, but each has a shortcomming. For the Mariner, the problem is the shower/tub combination that exists in most suites, and the head room is a bit sparse for taller fokls taking a shower. For the Voyager, the problem is that sometimes suites near the stern are subject to undue vibration --- and reportedly sometimes not. So if you book a suite near the Voyager stern, there's a bit of a gamble involved.

The Navigator is a smaller ship and transports only 490 guests maximum. The base suites are large like on the Voyager, BUT, you have to book two categories up to get a balcony. Like the Voyager, the Nagivator has some vibration issues, but usually low and to the stern, and effecting public areas more than any suites. We voted for the Navigator. Main reason is we like small ships. Also, recently some Navigator cruises have been priced less that comparable Voyager cruises to allow for that upgrade -- or to allow for a more economical cruise for those who don't need balconies. In our vote, we assumed such pricing were in effect, making balcony suites on all three ships the same price.If this were not the case, and the balcony on the Navigator were higher, our vote would be a tie between Mariner and Voyager.

Thanks,
Richard :) :) :)


"It's five o'clock somewhere."