Remember Wendy it was the $1K you lose as a credit (paying free air price) plus the coach fare price (some were as much as $1969)PLUS the $499 fee they charged as well.

Those coach fares varied a lot depending on the cruise and the gateway city. This year they are just making it all the same and doing away with the upgrade fee of $499.

So to round it out at the most expensive coach air fare it really was $1000 + $1900 + $500 = $3400 last year for business class air.

This year it is the $1000 (paying free air price) and $2500 so a total of $3500.00.

So they really went up for those who had a lower air fare gateway city but stayed the same or down very slightly for those with the more expensive gateways.

It is just a lot easier this way.