Sue, before our PG trip last December, we stayed 1 night at the Intercontinental. (We did our own air so the hotel pre-cruise was arranged on our own.) I would highly recommend doing this. It was so nice to board the ship in the early afternoon, do some exploring, and take care of "business" such as restaurant and spa reservations and picking up snorkeling gear. I feel it would be much more rushed to board after the ATN flight arrives, unless you are pressed for time. We are sailing the PG again in December and have arranged our air and hotel the same way - flying in one day early.
The IC Beachcomber was very nice. We had a panoramic room for our 1 night pre-cruise (post we did one night in a OWB). For us, for one night pre, it would not have been worth the extra cost for the OWB. For two nights (so that you get one full day) it would be worth it. We were pooped on arrival Friday night - we sneaked some peeks at the Tahitian show (easy to do from the bar area) and went to sleep. Saturday was gray and rainy so we explored the Beachcomber, went for a walk off-property, relaxed a bit, then it was time to go to the PG. IC Beachcomber is very close to the airport, so close in fact that when we were in the OWB, we thought a jet was about to land on us in the middle of the night. We did not hear any airport noise in the panoramic room - maybe because we were so tired! Any way it's a quick taxi ride from the airport.
Here is a great tip I got from LCT folks. If you upgrade your Priority Club membership to Gold Ambassador, at a cost of $150, you get a guaranteed one-category upgrade and guaranteed late checkout. This was well worth the cost for us, and you also get a coupon for one free weekend night following one paid. Due to our schedule we could not use the free night in Tahiti, but we used it for a fun weekend in San Francisco. If you use RSSC air/hotel this would probably not help you but it worked great for us. I don't think that regular Priority Club will get you an upgrade, though it never hurts to ask.
Dena