I like the production shows and I don't think they are amateurish. But, I don't expect Broadway quality. They are simply an entertaining diversion to top of a wonderful meal in Compass Rose or the other dining rooms.
Admittedly, some of the shows are better than others. I enjoy watching the young singers and dancers honing their craft and also getting to know them during the day as they perform other functions around the ship. Some go on to greater heights maybe even becoming that Broadway performer. It's fun to watch their progress. As you can see, I'm looking at this from a slightly different persepctive. If I attended expecting Tony quality performances, I would be disappointed.
Since I haven't sailed on another line, I don't have a means of entertainment comparison. I do agree that some of the "booked" entertainers are sketchy and I usually don't go back for their second performance. There have also been some outstanding ones, but it's too early in the morning for me to recall their names. I need more coffee!
I also agree that the lectures are hit and miss. I've seen some wonderful ones and also some real duds.