I would not worry too much. This is just one persons opinion after all and her perception of things. I always say take all the reports you can then average them all out. If every report you read on Silversea said the same thing - then worry. However, you will also find rave reviews on Silversea. If you are on the Whisper or Shadow I do think those two newer ships are superior to the Wind and Cloud. Many people who love Silversea though prefer the Wind and the Cloud. That is the problem with reviews - we must always remember it is ONE person opinion.