Here is our take on our recent Silver Whisper cruise from Dubai to Athens (on which we had the great pleasure to meet Eugene & Gail):
Service: Marvelous, even better than Regent. A number of members of the waitstaff and bar staff took great care to remember passengers' preferences. Our cabin attendants (SS still uses teams of two, as opposed to the unfortunate Regent change to a single attendant) were superb - cheerful, responsive, and efficient.
Food: The weak point of the cruise, as compared to Regent. As Eugene mentioned, it is quite inconsistent. At the same table, one of us received a dish at proper temperature, while another received the identical order at the entirely wrong temperature (i.e. slices of pork tenderloin that were not even warm and were smothered by a room temperature sauce or a dessert plate with ice cream that was melted and therefore ran all over the other items on the plate). One night, of four orders of the chocolate souffle, one was properly baked, two were somewhat undercooked, and one was completely runny and inedible. A poster on CC who was on the Singapore to Dubai cruise on Whisper also had problems with food quality control. Perhaps the new Exec Chef on Whisper does not understand how to run a restaurant on a ship. Previous Silversea cruisers told us that they considered these food problems to be quite uncharacteristic of SS. Further, we are encouraged that passengers on other recent SS cruises (such as Debbie on the Shadow) do not report such quality control problems. One would hope that either the new Exec Chef on Whisper will get a handle on the quality control problems or will be replaced with someone who can.
Excursions: We found the Tour Desk to be more knowledgeable about ports than the Regent desk has been. Further, unlike Regent, there were always SS reps on each tour (and even each tour bus). We were more fortunate that Eugene in Jeddah - we took the full day tour and had an excellent experience.
Disembarkation: We agree heartily with Eugene that the process was handled very well. The luggage was organized perfectly in the terminal building, with a number of SS personnel there to assist as needed. That has not been our experience on Regent in some cases.
Passenger mix: We loved the more diverse passenger mix and would not hesitate to take another SS cruise, irrespective of whether it was escorted.
Summary: Assuming that the food problems do not become a pattern at SS, we would be quite happy to sail on either Regent or SS, making the choice based on itinerary and fare. Overall, this SS experience - our first - was excellent.
Cheers, Fred