Thank you all for your input.
Claudia the reason that I didn't want to go to Cabo is that I love turquoise water like they have in the Caribbean. I also wanted to keep Marty away from those expensive fishing boats.I would love to go to a place with nice coral. We enjoy snorkeling although the Great Barrier Reef ruined us forever. It was so perfect.
Karen we are seriously considering Secrets. I had selected it before your post. We just have to decide if we can stand that long of an airplane trip for spending only a week there. We were concerned about the weather. We have always been to the Caribbean in April or May. If we do end up going in the summer I like that it is all adults. I get a little tired of hearing Marco Polo all day unless it is coming from my grandchildren of course.