Hi Wendy: We were on Mariner in Alaska last August and both HAL and Princess were in port in Vancouver with us when we left, and in some of the ports with us.
We have cruised HAL before, not the others. HAL now has instituted As You Wish dining on their ships and so set dining is not necessary on that line, but is still available if the passenger wishes.
HAL is not my favorite cruise line and we have had some issues with them, but I think the profile would fit your friends age and is nice for first time cruisers.
We prefer Regent overall and love the dining when you wish. But, if one is going to choose another line in Alaska, I highly recommend that they do not book the huge ships of Princess or HAL. I'd avoid the VISTA class on HAL and sail on the S or R class like the Amsterdam or the Ryndam. On Princess, I'd try to sail the Tahitian Prince size ships which hold only 700 passengers, rather than the Sapphire Princess size which have 2800 passengers.
The HAL Vista ships like the Oosterdam and Westerdam are fine, but really big and do not get into the ports the same way the smaller ships can. Tendering is more normal on those, I've found.
Your friends should easily be able to get a balcony or even a suite on HAL for under $2500pp. In fact, many oceanviews have gone for under $600pp.
I hope they have a wonderful time in Alaska. It's very nice of you to help them make a great memory.
Kathy :)