I guess I didn't realize they were in their 70's. I'd really suggest HAL in that case, their demographic does tend to be a bit more mature.
I guess I'd price out both HAL and even Regent and factor in things such as a balcony (you really should have one in Alaska), the food quality (Regent is by far superior) and the all-inclusive aspect of Regent. The "little things" like paying for ALL beverages and tipping can really add up.