I've done both Princess and Celebrity to Alaska before - admittedly it was some time ago so my observations may no longer be applicable. For that kind of money, you should definitely be able to get a balcony though with HAL, it might be a little more. I"m a real big fan of open seating rather than being told when and whom I'm eating with so just for that reason, I like Princess (Personal Choice dining). I did think that the food on Celebrity was slightly better but it was not enough of a difference to really sway me.

If I was to do it again, I might have tried HAL but the fixed seating still bothers me. Actually, for Alaska, I'd probably go with HAL or Princess since they're the two companies with the biggest presence in Alaska historically.

Masaki