Charlene, (I'm no expert but I have been to Rome several times).
I would recommend a private tour (I love Remo) for approximately 6-7 hours. Don't cut it too close driving back to the ship! Expect the unexpected!
I know from past experience that Remo is a wiz knowing the quickest backroad routes around Rome to avoid traffic.
You will be able to see all the highlights of Rome in this time frame with the most time probably spent at St. Peter's. I would concentrate all my time just seeing sites in Rome only. There is nothing worth seeing around Civitavecchia.


Marcie