I have booked Claudio for my day in Rome (September 13th), and am confident that it will be a wonderful tour, after reading all these glowing reports. Also, Claudio set me up with two "associates" for Florence (September 10th) and the Amalfi Coast (September 14th), as he is busy. Hope they're as charming and informative as he is! I'll certainly let you know.
I like the flexibility limo-in-Rome gives me. Claudio had a "suggested" Amalfi Coast tour that included Pompeii, which we didn't want (we'll be in Pompeii the week before on the first leg of our trip). He quickly amended it for me, concentrating on the coast itself, going a little further, having a leisurely lunch etc, which suited me better. And the "associate" he has driving us is from Sorrento, and Claudio said he'd know exactly where to take us for lunch, which is great.
I think we'll just take a ship tour to Pompeii the first week. Has anyone done this ship excursion??
Charlene