Luxury Cruise Talk Logo

Keene Luxury Travel
800-856-1155 · 972-701-9292
Join Our Mailing List · Email us

Who's Online Now
1 registered members (Davefr), 63,298 guests
Newest Members
marg, Matthew_Corps77, JLdB, Obiliro, ConnorWood(41385 Registered Users)
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186173 01/12/08 02:57 PM
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 27
N
NJBelle Offline OP
cruiser
OP Offline
cruiser
N
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 27
Hello All,
I have been a bit quiet lately - so wanted to say Happy New Year to everyone! We got back from a great 14 day cruise in South Africa about a week ago. We had a wonderful time, and I had made a committment to myself to actually write a reivew of the cruise, esp since there is not much SS discussion here or on CC (relative to Regent, anyway!).

I just posted a reivew of the cruise on Cruise Critic (hope it is okay that I am mentioning that board - I know we cannot do the converse for some reason....). I can just cut and paste here if people would be interested or just tell you where it is on CC: I just went under the Silversea section and started a new thread.

Either way - if you read it and then have questions, I will be happy to answer them. You are all so willing to share your knowledge, that I just felt like I need to share our experience with others as well.

Best, Janice

Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186174 01/12/08 03:19 PM
Joined: Jan 1970
Posts: 15,174
KarenS Offline
Moderator
Offline
Moderator
Joined: Jan 1970
Posts: 15,174
Janice, it sounds as if you had a marvelous time!! I am dying to try Silversea in the near future!


Karen

Live long and prosper
Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186175 01/12/08 03:27 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 11,641
joannapv Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 11,641
Thanks Janice - I am dying to read your review - like Karen I want to try SS too - editing I just read it and enjoyed it very much - I really enjoyed meeting Katherine on Fjords -


Joanna
Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186176 01/12/08 03:48 PM
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,447
Sue&TomInGeorgia Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,447
Please post your review Janice. We have never sailed SS and will try them one day.


Sue
"A vacation is having nothing to do and all day to do it in" Robert Orben
*******
Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186177 01/12/08 04:03 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 10,095
petlover Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 10,095
Me too Janice...would love to read it. No problem mentioning cc on this board whatsoever.


Marcie

Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186178 01/12/08 06:34 PM
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 27
N
NJBelle Offline OP
cruiser
OP Offline
cruiser
N
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 27
Hi everyone - below I have pasted the exact same reivew I just posted in Cruise Critic. So, if some of you read both boards, this may sound familar. But this way, we can chat here and I can answer any specific quesitons that LCT folks have. Here goes....

As previously promised, here is a more detailed review of the Silver Cloud cruise from Dec 22 through Jan 5. My time to put this together is rather limited, so I have allowed myself an hour for this. So, it will not be as detailed as some may like, but at least I will try to hit the major points. (This has also given me a new appreciation for all those people who do take the time to share their experiences with others!).

Overall, the cruise was just wonderful. Many things were just great and almost could not be improved upon. Others were not the best in the industry, but that may have been due to the size of the ship (300 passengers) and what is possible for that size of ship. There were a couple of things that Silversea could fix and one that they MUST fix. (More on all of those in the review later on).

We are in our early 50's and have a 13 year old daughter. This was our 13th cruise (7 on Crystal, 4 on Regent and 2 on SS), and our 5th holiday cruise.

General: The itinerary started in Cape Town and included Namibia; the rest of the stops were South African ports. Total length was 14 days, with 5 full sea days and several half sea days; we had 3 overnights in Walvis Bay, Richards Bay and Cape Town. The ship was full and there was a festive air. Nice, but not over the top decorations. Passenger mix was heavily international. I did not do an analysis of the passenger list, but it seemed like it was about 40% American, lots of Brits and Aussies, a fair number of Italians and the rest from various places around the world. (There was one group - a networking group from the US; this was about 70 passengers total, so that really made up the majority of the American passengers. And contrary to some other "groups", this one was very nice, congenial, etc. No problems whatsoever. I did hear one night that they had had a special barbeque set up on the pool deck, but that was only in response to my observation to the head waiter that the Dining Room seemed quiet.) There were not many kids on this cruise (and we really had not expected that there would be). Because this was an active port cruise (lots of game drives, etc) and Cape Town is also not the easiest city to get to, I wonder if that is why we didn't see a lot of really elderly passengers. I don't recall but maybe one wheel chair, and no scooters. (On our holiday Caribbean cruises, the scooters would just about get into gridlock at mealtimes sometimes). Therefore, even though the average age was likely what many other cruises are, it was due to a clustering around a 50-70 age range and to the lack of really young passengers and really old passengers.

There were 4 formal nights, 5 informal and 5 casual nights. On formal nights, we noticed that about 75% of the men wore tuxedos (or similar national/cultural formal ware). I guess because it was a holiday cruise, it was more formal; we also noticed that on "casual" night, some of the women were really in more "informal" mode, but there is always a variation. In general, this was a pretty formally dressing crowd.

Service: I have previously said the service was the best we have ever had on any cruise. When we were on SS before, the service was good, but it was a bit cold and more aloof. Now there are more Filipino staff and I believe they have brought a warmth to the overall service. We had noticed the infusion of Filipino staff in the dining room on Regent a couple of years ago, and while they were very eager to serve, they did not have the polish and skill sets of the more European staff that we had been used to on Crystal. Now, I think that the polish, warmth and skill sets are all there - it was the whole package on this SS cruise. Again, I cannot think of a single time anyone said "no" to me. One morning, the seas were a little rough and I didn't feel like having a big breakfast. I went to the Panorama Lounge and asked for some ginger herbal tea. The waiter went away and then came back and said that while they didn't have any ginger tea bags, he would be happy to make me up a ginger infusion - and he went and minced some fresh ginger and made me tea on the spot. Hedi, the Maitre'D, was excellent - seemed he always turned up just when my daughter was getting ready to cut her steak or chicken (I was afraid that she would still be looking for Hedi once we got home!) And one final example, on New Year's Eve, we had a lovely fixed menu (choice of main course) but as it turns out, none of the courses was really going to be what my daughter was interested in. But the waiter didn't blink an eye and the kitchen happily turned up with a whole separate meal for my daughter on the spot. Also, noticed lots of nice touches - there was not a paper napkin to be found anywhere on the ship. For drinks, anything - always received a nice folded cloth napkin. Around the bar, they used a very high quality polycarbonate "glassware" - so that no one would ever have to worry about stepping on any glass.

Also, our stewardess was the best we have ever had. On all of our previous cruises, we have found the stewardesses to be the most "hit or miss". Some speak very little English and others are not very efficient, etc. This time we hit the jackpot - ours was just wonderful. I like it on SS when they have the stewardess accompanied by an assistant - that way, even though they have more rooms to handle, they can get in and out of each room very quickly. We were never inconvenienced a single time, and anything we asked for, arrived very quickly.

Also, room service is great on SS. The waiter comes quickly and brings tablecloth, etc and sets up a nice table wherever you want it - either on the table in the sitting area, or outside on the verandah.

Suites: These was just lovely - we like the Regent and Silversea suites much better than Crystal - bigger with other extras. We like the walk-in closet and the closing draperies between the sitting area and the sleeping area. Traveling with a teenager, it was great to be able to close the curtains and then when we got up earlier than she did, she could continue to sleep. Same if she wanted to go to bed earlier than we - or stay up later - we didn't disturb each other. The bathrooms on the Cloud are not as big as the Whisper, but ours was fine, and worked for us. Temperature of room was no problem. I was going to report that the bedspreads were tired, but on the morning we were disembarking, they were changing out all the mattresses and bedspreads across the whole ship.

Here is the thing that SS HAS to fix: I went down half way during the cruise to do laundry. There is only one laundry room on the whole ship, but since it is a small ship, I figured that would be okay. I had to plot to be able to get two machines at one time - and considered myself lucky when I got there first thing in the AM and was able to snag 2 machines. Well, 3 hours later, my clothes were still not dry. The washing machines were fine, but the dryers really didn't dry. I found out later that it was well known that "the ones on the end" didn't dry well.....and of course, I got the ones on the end. I complained to the front desk and to the Cruise Consultant and also put in on my response card at the end of the cruise. It is just unacceptable for passengers on a luxury cruise to have crappy old machines which do not dry as their only option besides sending all dirty clothes to be laundered by the cruise ship for a price. The Cruise Consultant thought that they might be replacing them in the next dry dock, but that is not until spring of 2009, and I don't think SS should wait on something like this. This might require ordering some parts/new machines, and closing down the laundry for a day or two - but that is better that passengers having to waste so much time waiting for clothes to dry and then having to spread wet underwear around their suites when they finally give up! Okay, enough on that.

Food: Was excellent without caveat. Tobias Schreiber is the new chef on the Cloud, but we had known him from Regent. He has a great personality and we really enjoyed the cooking demos that he did (2 on the 14 day cruise). The pastry chef was also fabulous - and every night there would be a special chocolate offering. My daughter and I will always have the night we ate 2 "assiettes de chocolat" each as a fond memory. In fact, the pastry chef was probably too good (judging from the scale!).

Wine: the house champagne pour is Pommery. I found it to be a bit sweet, so was happy with the Mumm's. (But for any people about to go on SS, you have to ASK for the Mumm's or they will serve the Pommery). There was some Nicholas Feuillate, but they didn't get a big shipment of that, so I didn't get to have that but a couple of times. The other complimentary wines were excellent. Lots of South African wines, and the Head Sommelier, Ana, did a nice wine tasting on SA wines. During the tasting, she also popped the cork off a champagne bottle (actually took the glass end of the bottle off) by rubbing a knife along the seam of the bottle. It was very dramatic and I had never seen that demonstrated before. Bar service everywhere was fast, and we drank only one beer from our room supplies. I did order some wine for lunch from room service and they brought a whole bottle - even though it was only for me. (In case, you are wondering, I didn't drink it all!)

Entertainment: Here is where you can tell this is a small ship. There was a show each evening, but the quality varied. We are not ones to always go to shows, and if fact, prefer the piano bar type of entertainment after dinner. We like the entertainment like in the Avenue Saloon on Crystal or in the various lounges on Regent. Even on our last SS cruise on the Whisper, there was a singer/piano player we enjoyed. Alas, they only had a piano player - who was quite competent, but we didn't feel a rapport and so didn't go listen to him but once. We found that we enjoyed the dinners so much, that we would linger with coffee, dessert, enjoying the last of our wine, etc - if we were not going to the show. So, it worked out okay, but we would have liked the option of a cabaret type of offering.

Lectures: On this cruise, we had an excellent lecturer - Andrew Roberts. He is a historian from London who has written a number of books on modern historical topics. He had a dry sense of humor and an nice speaking style and we enjoyed every one of his 4 lectures. The only problem is that he was the only one on this cruise. For such a long cruise, SS should have had more than one lecturer.

Excursions: These were good and there were always SS staff along with the passengers. No particular comments on this, except to say that we were very pleased with what we did. I mentioned earlier that we went on 3 day safaris and while they were all similar in some ways, they were all different in others and we enjoyed every minute. Oh! I should mention the complimentary excursion on Christmas Eve. SS used buses and 4x4s to get us all out on the Namib Desert. It was just a fabulous evening. We left the little town of Walvis Bay and then before we knew it, we were seeing the rolling sand dunes like something out of a movie. When we arrived at the tents, there was music, local singers in African dress, flowing wine, lots of food - and camels to ride! All of us rode at different times (our daughter was out climbing the huge sand dune while my husband and I rode) and we all thought it was very cool. The colors of the evening as the sun went down and the magic in the air are just indescribable. I think this is something that SS offers every time it goes to Namibia, so if you even have a chance to go, don't miss it.

Misc: On SS, there are not art auctions, photo taking or strolling musicians in the Dining Room. I was happy about that, and did not miss that in the least!

Smoking: I was worried that because Regent has tightened up its smoking restrictions, all the smokers might flock to SS and then it would be very uncomfortable for non-smokers. While I saw a few people smoking, they did stay in the designated areas and it was not bothersome. The only time that someone was really rude was an Italian woman who was smoking in the long line for the toilet during one of the stops on an excursion. I was coming out of the bathroom at the time, so was glad to be able to keep moving.

Tips: Of course, SS is an all-inclusive line, so we did not tip the staff. However, I do have one quick anecdote for those who are wondering how to reward great service. Because it was a holiday cruise, I did take little Christmas bags for the 2 stewardess and put money and a couple of pieces of candy in each and gave that to them on Christmas morning. They nicely thanked me and that was that. After the first few days of the cruise, SS sends out an interim "how are we doing" survey and I saw that it suggested that in addition to any complaints, that if there were any staff members to commend, they would be happy to hear about that as well. One of the people that I highlighted was the aforementioned great stewardess. I had forgotten about that until the next day, when she practically rushed up to me to thank me for my kind words and recommendation in the survey. So, if anyone is ever wondering what is more valuable to them - that showed me that she had been happier about the recommendation than the money (although, I am sure that she was happy to have both!). So, if there are people who are making you happy on a cruise, be sure to mention them by name in those written surveys - it does count a lot, it seems.

Okay, my time is up. As you see, except for dryers, it was a heavenly cruise. We are signed up for another SS cruise next Christmas as well! Let me know if you have any questions.

Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186179 01/12/08 10:07 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,369
Beth Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,369
Janice, Thanks so much for your detailed review. Glad you had such a great cruise. We sailed on the Silver Wind in 06 and found it to be a wonderful ship. Loved the size.

When you get time, would you go into more detail on the ports and excursions? I would really like to hear more about your safari, also.

Many thanks

Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186180 01/13/08 05:15 AM
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 9,100
Ngaire Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 9,100
Tobias, Silversea's gain and Regent's loss. I always enjoyed Tobias, he is a chef with a personality. He left Regent, then he came back and now I guess he has left again.

Great review thank you for taking the time to write that for us all. I really enjoyed reading your report.

Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186181 01/13/08 01:19 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,215
adrenn Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,215
Janice - Happy New Year. When are we playing POOCH again with Katherine?

Thanks for the review. I've been slightly leery of booking Cloud/Wind vs. Shadow/Whisper. From your experience, I should let go of that hesitation.

Glad you enjoyed your trip! The itinerary is certainly great.

Ngaire .. I'll start the ball rolling we request Tobias on CAMEL. He's wonderful and would be a great addition to our merriment. I want to see him riding alongside me on a CAMEL. However, I will pass on the Camel Tartare (LOL!) appetizer


Cheers, Anne

Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186182 01/13/08 02:57 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,821
Suzie Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,821
Yes indeed, we need Tobias on the Whisper. There's more room in the galley! Work your magic Ngaire :D


Suzie

The days pass happily with me wherever my ship sails.
- Joshua Slocum
Re: Silver Cloud: Dec 22 to Jan 5 #186183 01/16/08 04:37 AM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
DebbieH103 Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
Janice, I posted my comments on CC, as you know. I just wanted to thank you again for the review and the information on Africa, as we are booked there next year on Wind.

We love both sized ships on SS, and I am glad it was still a good experience except for the dryers. On Wind when we went, I didn't like the whole looks of that laundry room, and I didn't see any soap. A stewardess followed us in there like we shouldn't be there. It was a thing that made me uncomfortable briefly, but our trip was for 8 days, so we did alright without, and I didn't give it much thought.

I hope from your report and my Dubai one that people see how neat the desert safaris are. Yours sounds just fantastic.


Moderated by  KarenS 

Keene Luxury Travel Offers
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.3